Payne Gap Cemetery Directory

Recognized by the Texas Historical Commission as an Historic Texas Cemetery, the Payne Gap Cemetery is located at 1511 FM 572 East, about fifteen miles east of Goldthwaite, Mills County. It occupies about one acre of fenced-in land situated about forty-five feet to the east of the Payne Gap School. The cemetery and school are the only remaining landmarks from the community of Payne Gap, which was named after Barzilla Payne, the first Anglo to settle the area starting in 1857. He and his wife are buried about a mile south of the cemetery on private property. The only known deed related to the cemetery is from 1905 that gave the Payne Gap School trustees four acres from property owned by W.F. Hearne to expand the school grounds. This land appears to have included the cemetery, though there is no explicit reference to it in the deed. The headstone of Laura E. Carswell (1825–1889) identifies her as the first buried at the cemetery, and the entrance gate bears her death date, 1889, though there are likely earlier, unidentified graves. Probably the most notable person buried at the cemetery, John Motley Hensley (1806–1898) was a settler at Austin’s Colony and a soldier at the Battle of San Jacinto. “Mattie” [Payn] Jenkins was the daughter of Barzilla Payne and also the wife of Payne Gap’s first postmaster, Richard Jenkins.

The cemetery’s charter and bylaws lays out burial policies and other managerial matters. Email questions to paynegapcemetery@gmail.com.

Cemetery Statistics

[cemetery_stats]

Directory Usage Tips

  • Click last name to view full record; click row and grave info to view map.
  • Default sort is by last name then given name; click any other column heading to change sort; repeat click on column to reverse sort.
  • Deceased with blue highlighting have been updated within the last thirty days.

Donate

Make a donation to help support the administration, maintenance, preservation, and improvement of the cemetery.

[cemetery_table]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *